Blog
Before You Invoke Appraisal on a Texas Property Claim
When your insurance company’s repair estimate falls short of yours, the next step depends on why the numbers differ. For Texas homeowners and business owners, an insurance policy’s appraisal clause may offer a way to resolve a disagreement over the amount of a property loss. It is not the same as reopening negotiations, and it does not settle every type of claim dispute.
Start by reading the appraisal provision in your policy, including any endorsements that change it. Many provisions allow either the policyholder or the insurer to demand appraisal, with each side selecting an appraiser and the two appraisers selecting an umpire. The policy controls the qualifications, notice requirements, selection procedures, and other conditions that apply.
During appraisal, the appraisers review the damage, estimates, photographs, and other supporting records, and they may inspect the property. They work to determine the amount of loss and try to reach agreement. If they cannot agree, they submit their differences to the umpire; under many policy provisions, agreement by any two establishes the appraisal award.
Appraisal generally addresses the amount of loss rather than deciding whether the policy provides coverage. Some disagreements about repair scope and damage causation can overlap with valuation, so the distinction is not always simple. An award does not automatically mean the insurer must pay the full stated amount, because coverage terms, deductibles, prior payments, and other policy provisions still matter.
Consider invoking appraisal when there is a documented, unresolved disagreement over repair quantities, pricing, materials, or the cost to repair versus replace damaged property. Before doing so, submit your supporting estimate and records, ask the insurer to explain the differences, and give it an opportunity to address missing items. If the central issue is a coverage denial or policy interpretation, appraisal alone may not resolve it, and legal guidance may be appropriate.
Weigh the potential benefit against the expense before sending a demand. Under many policies, each side pays its own appraiser and shares the umpire’s fee and other appraisal expenses, but you should confirm your policy’s wording. Keep any demand and response in writing, and do not assume appraisal pauses claim duties, repair obligations, or legal deadlines.
A useful appraisal file includes the policy, insurer estimates and letters, contractor estimates, photographs, and a clear list of disputed items. Understanding both the disagreement and the policy procedure can help you decide whether appraisal is a practical next step. Catastrophe Loss Consultants offers free claim reviews for Texas property owners who would like help assessing their claim and available next steps.
